Research Nurses in Orthopaedics
Gayle Walley BSc(Nurs)
Orthopaedic Surgical Trial Unit
Departrment of Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgery
Keele University School of Medicine
Thornburrow Drive
Harsthill, Stoke on Trent ST4 8FB Staffs
ENGLAND
Tel: + 44 1782 55 48 46
Fax: + 44 1782 41 22 36
Nursing research is complex, and
relatively little nursing research has been undertaken (Bassett and Hopkins
2001). The role of research nurse in trauma and orthopaedics is vast and
multi-faceted, and can vary considerably (Williams and Gumbrell 1990), but can
be extremely important to the successful implementation and completion of
clinical studies. The research nurse is involved in all aspects of the
research process, including assisting in the initial writing of the
protocol. Successful coordination of multidisciplinary, collaborative
research relies heavily on the qualities that constitute the "art" of
nursing, especially those of interpersonal communication skills (Martin
1994). Whilst having an in-depth knowledge of the research process is
fundamental to the research nurse role, past experience will also determine the
feasibility of a planned project (Dunn 1991). The role involves the
education of clinicians and nurses about the study protocols, and strengthening
the links between clinicians and researchers can help to enhance this process.
The research nurse can enroll
patients into studies, administer study interventions, and record data, acting
as the link between the study subjects and the investigative team (Pranulis
1997). Conflict between roles as caregiver versus researcher can occur
(Hagle, Barbour, Flynn, Kelley, Trippon, Braun, Beschorner, Boxler, Hange,
McGuire, Bressler and Kirchhoff 1987), and therefore attempts should be made to
minimise such conflicts (McGuire et al 2000). The nurse has to balance
patient advocacy and responsibilities to the study and the study contributors
(Stanfield and Simon 1991) to ensure that the role is carried out proficiently.
Scientists often tend to function
under the illusion that, when a research study is planned, patients will
respond like "experimental subjects" (Gross and Fogg 2001). In
our setting, the research nurse is responsible for the screening of all
potential study patients according to the eligibility criteria central to the
study. This is often time consuming, especially in the constraints of
clinics when patients have to see so many members of the multi-disciplinary
team, and regular hospital staff have many other duties that compete for their
attention (Friedman et al 1998).
The research nurse should use
strategies to ensure adherence by informing the patient in as much detail as
possible on what the trial involved and what was expected from them: a truly
informed participant is a better adherer (Becker 1990 and Green 1979).
The provision of an information sheet to take away also reinforces what has
already been discussed. Good communication skills and a more thorough
delivery of the intervention are vital in ensuring that all members adhere to
the protocol to ensure the trial runs smoothly and the results may be
generalized.
The research nurse must ensure that
the patient is given all the necessary information to make an informed choice,
and must promote the interests of the patient (UKCC 1992). The patient
must be given the opportunity to think over the information, thereby offering
the patient a choice as to whether to participate in the study (O'Brien 1997).
The research nurse's sensitivity to
the moral implication of the research, and firm adherence to a professional
code of practice, ensures sound foundations for the security and well being of
all who participate in the research or contribute to the process in any
way. Patients' perception of quality and satisfaction with care appear to
be strongly connected with impressions of practitioner interpersonal and
clinical competence, and the nature and significance of the relationships
cultivated between the nurse and the patient (French 1981; Kitson 1986 and
Cleverley 1990). Providing an honest but approachable relationship with
the patient/client can help to ensure patients feel both comfortable in
entering research studies and also feel satisfied with the
process.
Although the roles and
responsibilities of research nurses involved in clinical trials and studies
have been described (Crowley, Somelofski, Hill, Smith and Buchwald 1988;
Engelking 1991; Melink and Whitacre 1991; Seguin 1990; Stewart 1990 and
White-Hersey and Nevidjon 1990), published nursing research on the clinical
research nurse role is lacking. A multidisciplinary team approach to
research helps to disperse the traditional boundaries between health
professionals, between doctor and patient, and between managers and
clinicians. This enables a no-blame culture, excellent leadership and an
ethos of staff that feel valued and supported (Halligan and Donaldson
2001). Involving a wide range of stakeholders in uncovering the best
available evidence, and ascertaining the priorities and benefits from the
facts, leads to a sense of ownership and involvement (Kitson, McMahon, Rafferty
and Scott 1997). It allows for a culture more receptive to research and
the changes associated with it, and it emphasizes the importance in ensuring
evidence-based quality patient care.
The research nurse can help to
establish dedicated research clinics. This ensures that patients are
followed up and reviewed according to the protocol, and allows for continuity
of patients involved in the clinical studies. The research clinics allow
for time to follow-up patients without any interruptions, although follow-up
can be scheduled as much as possible to coincide with appointments with the
medical staff so as to inconvenience the patient as little as possible.
In conclusion, the role of the
research nurse in clinical research can be challenging. Conflict and
animosity can be prominent features initially; as staff may feel the role
impinges on systems already in place and may interfere with already
overburdened job roles. The research nurse role carries a considerable amount
of clinical autonomy (Johnson 1986 and Xanthos et al 1998), and yet much
experience can be gained by the whole research team while properly interacting
in a constructive fashion.
REFERENCES
American Nurses' Association
(1968) The nurse in research, ANA guidelines on
ethical values. American Journal of Nursing. Vol 68 No
7 pgs 1504-1507
Bassett C and Hopkins S (2001)The
importance of research in Nursing practice. Implementing Research in the
Clinical Setting. Whurr Publishers Ltd. London.
Becker MH (1990)Theoretical models
of adherence and strategies for improving adherence. In Schumaker SA,
Schron EB and Ockene JK (1990) Health Behaviour Changes. Springer.
New York.
Cleverley WO (1990) Improving
financial performance: a study of fifty hospitals. Hospitals and Health
Services Administration. Vol 35 pgs 173-187
Crowley S, Somelofski C, Hill M,
Smith J and Buchwald H (1988) Nursing and cardiovascular
clinical trials: successful outcomes. Cardiovascular Nursing. Vol
24 (5) pgs 25-30
Dunn B (1991) Who should be
doing the research in nursing? Professional Nurse. Jan
pgs 190-196
Engelking C (1991)
Facilitating clinical trials: The expanding role of the nurse. Cancer.
Vol 67 (6) pgs 1793-1797
French K (1981)Methodological
considerations in hospital patient opinion surveys. International Journal
of Nursing Studies. Vol 18 pgs 7-32
Friedman LM, Furberg CD and DeMets
DL (1998) Fundamentals of Clinical Trials. 3rd edn.
Springer-Verlag. New York.
Green LW (1979) Educational
strategies to improve compliance with therapeutic and preventative regimes: the
recent evidence. In Hayes RB, Taylor DW and Sackett DL (1979) Compliance
in Health Care. Johns Hopkins University Press. Baltimore.
Gross D and Fogg L (2001)
Clinical trials in the 21st century: The case for participant-centered
research. Research in Nursing and Health. Vol 24
pgs 530-539
Hagle ME, Barbour L, Flynn B,
Kelley C, Trippon M, Braun D, Beschomer J, Boxler J, Hange P, McGuire D,
Bressler L and Kirchhoff K (1987) Research collaboration among
nurse clinicians. Oncology Nursing Forum. Vol 14 (6)
pgs 55-59
Halligan A and Donaldson L
(2001)Implementing clinical governance: turning vision into reality. British
Medical Journal. Vol 322 pgs 1413-1417
Johnson JM (1986)Clinical trials:
New responsibilities and roles for nurses. Nursing Outlook. Vol
34 (3) pgs 149-153
Kitson A (1986)Indicators of
quality in nursing care-an alternative approach. Journal of Advanced
Nursing. Vol 11 pgs 133-144
Kitson A, McMahon A, Rafferty AM
and Scott E (1997) On developing and agenda to influence policy in
health-care research for effective nursing: A description of a national R
and D priority setting exercise. Nursing Times Research.
Vol 2 No 5 pgs 323-334
Martin KM (1994) Coordinating
multidisciplinary, collaborative research: a formula for success. Clinical
Nurse Specialist. Vol 8 No 1 pgs 18-22
McGuire DB, Delaney VG, Yeager KA,
Owen DC, Peterson DE, Lin LS and Webster J (2000) Maintaining study
validity in a changing clinical environment. Nursing Research. Vol
49 No 4 pgs 231-235
Melink T and Whitacre M
(1991) Planning and implementing clinical trials. Seminars in
Oncology. Vol 7 (4) pgs 243-251
O'Brien S (1997) The use of
wound drains in total hip replacement surgery. Journal of Orthopaedic
Nursing. Vol 1 (2) pgs 77-83
Pranulis M F (1997) Issues in
Clinical Nursing Research. Nurses Roles in Protecting Human Subjects. Western
Journal of Nursing Research. Vol 19 No 1 pgs 130-136
Seguin D (1990) My role as
research nurse coordinator. Critical Care Nursing
Quarterly. Vol 12 (4) pgs 39-44
Stanfield J and Simon J
(1991) The role of the staff nurse in clinical drug trials: A descriptive
study. Journal of Clinical Research and Pharmaco-epidemiology.
Vol 5 pgs 347-357
Stewart C (1990) Ambulatory
clinical trials: From concept to practice. Dimensions in Oncology
Nursing. Vol 4 (1) pgs 7-10
UKCC (1992) United Kingdom
Central Council for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting. The Scope of
Professional Practice. London.
White-Hersey D and Nevidjon B
(1990) Fundamentals for oncology nurse/data managers. Preparing for
a new role. Oncology Nursing Forum. Vol 17
(3) pgs 371-377
Williams Y and Gumbrell L
(1990) Cancer care and the research nurse. Nursing Standard.
Vol 5 No 6 pgs 30-32
Xanthos GJ, Carp D and Geromanos KL
(1998) Recognizing nurses' contributions to the
clinical research process. Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS
Care. Vol 9 No 1 pgs 39-48
|